Tuesday, September 04, 2007

It's totally cool, because we like totally solved poverty

The idea of that mega-projects can be a salve for economic developments, has been regarded with healthy skepticism since its heyday a few decades ago.* (Then again, maybe I am wrong. Maybe such projects are a sign of a healthy democracy). In any event, it is no surprise that Arab leaders are a little behind the curve. Middle East Development LLC has recently announced that they will start a project to connect Yemen and Djibouti. Although there is a large amount of trade and human movement between the Arabian Peninsula and Africa, I can't imagine that this is the most cost effective way to do this. The bridge will have to be able to accommodate the world's largest vessels (super-tankers, aircraft carriers, House of Saud party cruises etc.) and most cars in Yemen would have a difficult time driving that far in one stretch without breaking down. Will Somali pirates use it as another target of opportunity or hang out under it for shade? I wonder what the odds of this actually getting complete are.

Of course, Yemen and Djibouti are not the only Arab countries that have gone a little bridge crazy. The King Fahd Causeway (Bahrain-Saudi, pictured), the planned Friendship Bridge (Qatar-Bahrain) and another between Qatar and UAE are all fairly spectacular engineering feats, even taking into account the relative shallowness of the Gulf. Of course, the motivation for the bridges is probably more about getting the heck out of/totally avoiding going to Saudi Arabia than anything else, and Saudi knows it.

Then again, perhaps it is the romantic in me that dislikes these bridges, as it will only make more rare the sight of the graceful dhows making their way across the Indian Ocean, Red Sea and the Gulf.

*Simmer down, I can imagine the comments already. Yes, some big construction projects can be a vital part of economic development in the developing and developed world, but not always and what benefits they do have are often exaggerated.

7 comments:

sillybahrainigirl said...

Ouch! Where are the comments ..
Anyway .. Just wanted to add to your list of possible bridges, again involving the Saudis .. and connecting Saudi Arabia to Egypt! Read about it a while ago .. and then read a denial .. but you never know.. they could be building it right now!

Fayyad said...

Now that you volunteered that P.S. at the end, I'll this reminds me of Ted Stevens' $50 Million bridge to no where in Alaska...

Yemen, Djibouti and their neighbours combined do not have enough cars to justify the bridge, let alone cars that can make it across like you say, however, for any future trade or land transport between Africa and South East Asia that does nto depend on the mercey of Israel, they have to build a bridge, so it's strategic, and potentially economically viable. Which reminds me, I guess the Israeli navy left the island of Perim?

Roy said...

Two words: Djibouti call.

Anonymous said...

hello all
while i wanna make a coment the bridge seem the best way to help connect nations we all are human not animal and this is a globle world not disconnected world and time for african to benifit and work and trade with the weathy arab nations this is the greatest idea ever presented to the world and what are we doing booo'ng the idea before it go Please give credit to those who thought about it and get them to do the bridge where is yemen and djibouti government and noor city and MED what is going on give them a boost and get them going raly us and france to help and the un as well

thanks

Anonymous said...

This is one of the best ideas of human civilization. This move will benefit 680 million Africans and over 400 million Arabs.It's win win situation. Every body on both side (Africa and middle east) is very much exited about it - Somalia, Eritrea, Sudan, Ethiopia, Kenya, Uganda are already celebrating. Those who don't benefit directly should be happy for their fellow human being, but should not try to ruin for it, by publishing propaganda, by playing the terrorisms scare card again. That is selfish. The advent of internet - made the world politics a transparent one - every political move becomes a child's play. Those who wrote "Yemen-Djibouti BRIDGE Threatens Security" article - Don't waste your time - this project will go through by any means necessary because Africans and Arabs know what is good for them.

Anonymous said...

"..this project will go through by any means necessary because Africans and Arabs know what is good for them."

Do you honestly believe this? I can barely recall one instance of genuinely good leadership or governance in any African or Arabian state. Africa is, and will continue to be, a complete basket case, mainly due to corrupt, incompetent government. And Arabia is not much better... relying almost entirely on petrodollars earned from oil exports. In my opinion, neither region demonstrates the kind of able governance needed to analyse, review, decide, fund and complete a project of this scale. Dubai is a notable exception, but one oil fueled booming craze in one city does not inspire region-wide promise.

Anonymous said...

I have one Question Who is This Tarek Bin Ladin is he from the B.L. family or is he the other black sheep of the family how come no one from the BL Const. supporting or acknowledging the project as i know he has no money and no plan other than the Noor City company he hire and seem like they run away. Both government should own and protect this mega project no one should control this stratigic project (like USA, France, UN., Wolrd Bank, AU)
thanks
Tom J.