Friday, November 30, 2007

Much Ado About Something

Speaking of when religious conservatives attack, Sudanese officials jailed a British school teacher for her ghastly act of allowing the school children to name a teddy bear, Mohammad (gasp!).

Since there is not much else to worry about Sudan... right. It is hard not to see this as absurd, even from someone relatively non-judgmental as myself. However, there is a lot to learn about this, including the generally low state of mutual understanding in the world today -- one exacerbated by invasions, conflict and the irresponsible leaders stoking the flames.

There are glimpses of hope. BBC News asks in a quite sober way: when can the prophet's name be used? It finds that like almost everything else in Islam, opinions are divided depending on how strict the interpreter is. In short, Muslims cannot accuse the West of misunderstanding, and the West cannot accuse Muslims of acting as one unified, intolerant while, thanks to this BBC report.

Speaking of names, there is another way to look at this. The Teddy Bear is named after the 26th President of the United States, Teddy Roosevelt -- an avowed imperialist who sought American colonies and ports around the world. I would not expect the offended officials and clerics to know this, but it signifies that historical context cannot be forgotten.

I wonder if part of the reason for her jailing is that she is British, an identity viewed in Sudan in light of Britain's own imperial aims, including the conquering and re-conquering of Sudan more than 100 years ago. Britain, as America's right-hand man in the War on Terror, is seen as invader junior throughout the Arab world.

It may be her cultural naivete, or this may be a form of historical recrimination. It may the mirror image of American policies towards foreign Muslims -- stick them with the law whenever you can. In the US, it is with "anti-terrorism laws." There, it is with "incitement to religious hatred" or "demeaning Islam" laws. It also hard not to see this in the context of the Mohammad cartoon fiasco in late 2005; something fresh in the minds of people on both sides.

Forces in both countries are not letting this be a small issue. CNN-International (the decent version of CNN) reported that leaflets distributed earlier this week by Muslim groups promised a "popular release of anger" at demonstrations called for Friday. It also said that British newspapers condemned this, and one called for sanctions and recalling the ambassador. It is pretty plain that the Teddy Bear incident is not just because of a Teddy Bear, nor about the 15 days in jail.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

good thing this was a teddy bear as it allowed Will the perfect opportunity to bring up Imperialism. Well played my friend. Well played.

I've never been to the Sudan, so maybe I'm wrong here, but I highly doubt that they call it a teddy bear themselves. My guess is that they just call it (drumroll please....) a BEAR! (as they tend to do in most countries). So there is no "historical context" that plays into this story at all as stuffed animals have been around for centuries.

"I wonder if part of the reason for her jailing is that she is British, an identity viewed in Sudan in light of Britain's own imperial aims" - It almost seems that you would agree with such a jailing. And come on, do you honestly believe that if it was a Muslim woman, things would have been any different? This isn't the burbs, son. Sudan has some crazy shit going on.

nadia n said...

Those things may be a part of it, and you can't really separate these things, but I think this is more of a response to British pressure to put sanctions on Sudan lately.

Royone said...

The jailing might be for her protection while they get things in order to deport her safely.

There have been quite a number of people calling for her death...in the name of Allah, the merciful.

Nadeem said...

Does this mean I have to change my penis' name from Khadija to something lame and unoriginal, like "Russel The Love Muscle"?

Robin said...

American Islamic Congress Slams Sudanese Government Over Teddy Bear Case, Demands British Teacher Be Freed Immediately
http://www.earthtimes.org/articles/show/news_press_release,232123.shtml

Will said...

Thanks Robin.. I agree with the AIC completely.

Victor said...

Reading posts like this is funny and sad at the same time. I feel teleported to October 12, 1960, when Khruschev, called out for using a double standard in criticizing Western "imperialism" while denying the USSR's own imperialist colonial policies in Eastern Europe, beat his shoe on the table with rage.

You realize that as you write an article about British and American "imperialism", the very same nation under discussion - Sudan - is itself a result of Arab Islamic colonialism, and is in the process of openly courting Chinese economic imperialism.

More importantly, it is in the process of ethnically cleansing (i.e. through rape and mass murder, not the Palestinian-style "ethnic cleansing") millions of people in Darfur.

Keep banging that shoe, Will.
You commies never change.

Robin said...

She's been pardoned
http://abcnews.go.com/International/
wireStory?id=3944627

أبو سنان said...

Never mind the fact that a Muslim compant sold a bear with the name "Adam" the first Prophet.

Is it all prophets or just Mohammed. Some people have a reverence for Mohammed that borders on shirk. If they wanted this lady killed for blasphemy, how about the Islamic teddy bear that spoke Islamic phrases and was named after Adam?

These people are idiots.

Anonymous said...

"Commies"?

That's so 1950's. Besides, Will would never abuse his $800 Bruno Maglis like that.

thecutter said...

Knowing as much about media false flag ops as I do, this stinks of it. I believe that "something" happened, perhaps that she gave a name to a toy. But, it may have then been hyped to elements that are most hostile to either secularism or are seen as the most fundamentalist as she had "done something else", which we probably don't know what was said. This way, you get your photo ops of the Mad Fundamentalists in Sudan who are ruining this country, and "international intervention" could be acceptable, because they are a threat to any kind of life or democracy.

To me, it seems like the entire story is constructed, and perhaps one day, we will discover just that.