Tuesday, April 01, 2008

Israel has a problem with education

One of the unique things about attending a Palestinian university is the proximity you feel towards the conflict with the Israeli occupation. For decades, Palestinian universities were at the center of the resistance-where popular movements and social programs were pioneered, and where a large majority of political (and military) activists were recruited. Admittedly, since the end of the first intifada and the disaster that was Oslo, student activism has receded notably, though in no way has it ended.

The first time I realized that I’d be having a pretty different college experience than that of my friends in the US or the Arab world is when, a couple of months into my first semester at Birzeit University, I noticed a new student in my Arab Society class. Naturally, the professor asked him what he was doing showing up two months late. It turns out the student had just spent two years in the notorious Naqab (Katziot) desert prison for political activism, and had just gotten out.

The current head of the Student Union at Birzeit, Fadi Hamad, has been in an Israeli prison for the last 4 months without charge. His deputy, Abdallah Oweis, was arrested barely a month after taking over. He too is being held without charge. The Israeli occupation can ‘legally’ imprison Palestinians for up to six months at a time without charge, placing them in ‘administrative detention’. This can and usually is renewed every six months without any legal process. Some prisoners languish in administrative detention for years on end.

Of course, Israel doesn’t reserve its punishment to activists only. In 1987, it closed down every Palestinian educational institution, from kindergartens all the way to universities, for an entire year. For a whole year, students and children were not allowed to receive their education, a clear violation of international law. Palestinian society responded by setting up local educational committees that organized classes in ordinary homes. These had to take place in secret-if the Israeli army found out the time and place of these classes, all those taking part were arrested.

Although the 1987 closure was the most comprehensive, the universities, particularly Birzeit, Alnajah and Bethlehem, all faced independent closures for varying periods of time. Student dorms are frequently invaded by the army in the middle of the night, and road blocks are set up arbitrarily to impede the ability of students to reach their classes. From 2001 until 2004, the Israeli army set up a permanent checkpoint in Surda, between Ramallah and Birzeit. The route is used mostly by Birzeit students, and the checkpoint made a 15 minute trip an hour long nightmare. Students were turned back randomly, and many had to trek through the muddy hills in winter to get to school. Those that tried to go by road faced humiliation; at times, the soldiers would let students of a certain religion pass through, turning back the rest. Other times, the soldiers would line up the female students in two groups-those they deemed attractive, and those whose looks didn’t quite do it for the occupiers.

Birzeit University was set up in the 70’s as a liberal university, and it has played a leading role in developing social and political activism in support of the Palestinian cause. As such, it is known here as Jam’at al-Shuhada’, the University of Martyrs, in honor of the many alumni that have been killed by Israel since the university's inception. I’ve been at Birzeit for three and a half years – in that time, two students have joined that list.

Last year, Omar al-Thafer was killed by an undercover Israeli force in the heart of Ramallah in a botched assassination attempt that targeted a man eating at the same restaurant as he. Yesterday, Abdellatif Huroob, 20, from the village of Kharas near Hebron, was killed by an Israeli settler on a road near the illegal Israeli settlement of Gilo north of Ramallah. The Israeli army says Huroob was killed in self-defense when he tried to attack the settler. The autopsy revealed that he had been shot in the head at close range, execution style. Today, the Israeli army attacked his family home and ransacked it.

Omar and Abdellatif won’t be the last Palestinian students killed in cold blood by their occupiers, just like Fadi and Abdallah won’t be the last to be imprisoned for months at a time without charge. The truly tragic fact in all this is that such things have become an accepted part of the college experience in Palestine. I wonder if all those squealing in indignation about how Palestinian textbooks do not instruct Palestinian students to recognize the legitimacy of their occupier and oppressor (because plenty of American and Israeli studies have found that there is a shocking absence of anti-Semitism in these books) will ever be willing to raise their voices at the constant abuse of Palestinian students and educational institutions.

21 comments:

safiyyah bint world said...

masha allah, that was a good report, thank you.

Inna lillahi wa inna ilahi raji'un. may allah forgive abdellatif and grant him jennat al firdaus.

What would be the purpose of attempting to keep a population uneducated? What would be the purpose of cutting of access to means of working at supporting life for an entire population, bit, by bit, bit? What would be the purpose of cutting off everything a population would find absolutely necessary to survive?

Would it be, as our resident hywan Roy suggests they should do, to get the Palestinians to end a "war".... or to start one?

Rasheed said...

This is something I didn't know.

My heart goes out to the Palestinians trying to get an education and the Palestinians trying to educate their children.

Emily said...

Thank you for writing about this. I've heard several times before about the closures of universities in the 80s, but i didn't know the circumstances or dates.

Anonymous said...

thanks Mohammad. ya3teek al 3feya.

programmer craig said...

Education of Palestinians is proceeding just fine.

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSL0146737420080401

GAZA (Reuters) - Brandishing "the sword of Islam", a Palestinian boy stabbed President George W. Bush to death in a new puppet show for children aired by Hamas-owned television in the Gaza Strip.

Anonymous said...

Sadly, the real truth, which is not only profound- but carries more weight in time and space in illustrating the daily lives of the Palestinian students gets over-ridden by the garbage posted by programmar craig. An occurence which if done by Israelis would be dismissed as a "one-time episode that is irrepresentative and shoudn't be generalized to the entire populace."

programmer craig said...

I think the garbage HAMAS pumps out on it's private television channel is pretty profound too, anonymous. Profoundly hateful. Is that the kind of "political activism" that caused Palestinian Schools to be closed down in the past? I'm getting sick and tired of seeing these damn video clips that preach terrorism and murder coming out of Palestine. You are OK with that? The generation of Americans who will give Palestinians another chance hasn't been born yet. We Americans ALL saw the video of Palestinians dancing in the streets in Lebanon and the occupied territories, as the world trade center fell. We ALL saw that. And none of us will ever forget it. That's the PROFOUND reality on the ground here, even if most people won't say it out loud. Videos like this one just keep OUR hatred going. Or do you believe Arabs are the only ones capable of hate?

Guns said...

But anon 9:29 that would be applying the same standard to everyone irrespective of nation. That simply would not do.

Guns said...

and programmer, don't assume every American shares your prejudice and ignorance.

programmer craig said...

and programmer, don't assume every American shares your prejudice and ignorance.

I'm sure you have your own prejudice and ignorance, guns :D

There isn't any issue that ALL Americans agree on. But one thing i s for sure, Palestinians aren't very popular in the US, and that's not going to change any time soon. And that is nobody's fault but theirs. Arafat knew he was permanently screwed, the minute those images started playing on television.

Ismail said...

Hello-

This is your monthly reminder to ignore the postings of programmer craig, a pathetic little wanker who has nothing whatsoever to add the discussion and whose shrivelled heart beats faster each time some well-meaning soul responds to his provocations.

Recall please the final couplet of a fine Lewis Carroll poem:

"He only does it to annoy
Because he knows it teases."

That is all. Have a nice day.

Roy said...

Wow, the Palestinians sure have it hard. Maybe they should end the war.

nev said...

It's the casual face of genocide, attacking students like this.
And younger students in Hebron - http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=964067&contrassID=2&subContrassID=14

Anonymous said...

Ok, for those who have reading comprehension skills- I said, "not only profound- but carries more weight in time and space" Meaning, it has been reoccuring since the 1980s (time) and at various educational institutions (space), making it a precedent goal of Israel to deprive Palestinians the right to education. And Programmer craig, again, the garbage, which you poorly claim as evidence of your disillusionment, are only one-time occurences which doesn't effect the lives of Israelis. Cheering in streets and having puppet shows by extremists does not add up death tolls. Given how many jews felt relief with the downfall of Nazis, it's understandable for a small crowd to cheer when their oppressors (US) fall. But now that I see your hostility towards other posters, I know I'm wasting my time with an arrogrant prick.

Signed,
Not-an-ignorant-American

Roy said...

it's understandable for a small crowd to cheer when their oppressors (US) fall

The people in the World Trade Center were oppressing the Palestinians?

Or are they just big fans of collective punishment?

Cuz I heard they really hated it.

Anonymous said...

hmm...i think what Anon meant was that the Palestinians probably don't know what the world trade center was..that it's more a case of "they're experiencing what we experience when a group of lives are lost" kind of thing. If anything, the US gave aid to the oppression which was/is directly carried out by israel.

Anonymous said...

Roy- the innocent Palestinians that get killed are considered terrorists by Israeli soldiers? Or are they fans of collective oppression? Cuz I heard they hated it.

Roy said...

Roy- the innocent Palestinians that get killed are considered terrorists by Israeli soldiers?

Please explain why you're drawing some kind of equivalence between that and the Palestinians celebrating 9/11.

Nobody celebrates the death of Palestinian innocents.

Anonymous said...

hello Mohammad, my name is Laura Cornelius. I'm a journalist from Germany and would like to get in contact with you. I'm in Tel Aviv right now. You can find me on Facebook. Kind Regards, Laura

Anonymous said...

"Nobody celebrates the death of Palestinian innocents."

Sure they do, when they dubbed them with the label "terrorists".

Will said...

Laura Cornelius,

To contact any KABOBfest bloggers, e-mail admin@kabobfest.com

Will