What is your contact information? I will sue Kabob for defamation of reason.

Since westerners like you are befuddled about why people could be damaged by defamation against a religion, but seem to value legal traditions that give rights to sue to artificial entities like corporations, both could be pleased by this simple solution.

I think Islamic states are hypocritical for granting rights against defamation to both religion (collective) AND individuals — especially since individuals tend to have no other rights.

Will

“The defamation of religions protects ideas rather than individuals, and makes the state the arbiter of which ideas are true. It requires the state to sort good and bad ideologies.” By doing so, she said, the approach “violates the very foundations of the human rights tradition by protecting ideas rather than the individuals who hold ideas.”

A coalition of Islamic states is using the United Nations to enact international ‘anti-defamation’ rules

The trend has rights advocates worried for numerous reasons, beginning with the language used. If the notion of “defaming” a religion sounds a little unfamiliar, that’s because it is a major departure from the traditional understanding of what defamation means. Defamation laws traditionally protect individual people from being materially harmed by the dissemination of falsehoods. But “defamation of religions” is not about protecting individual believers from damage to their reputations caused by false statements — but rather about protecting a religion, or some interpretation of it, or the feelings of the followers. While a traditional defence in a defamation lawsuit is that the accused was merely telling the truth, religions by definition present competing claims on the truth, and one person’s religious truth is easily another’s apostasy. “Truth” is no defence in such cases. The subjective perception of insult is what matters, and what puts the whole approach on a collision course with the human rights regime — especially in countries with an official state religion.