Saad Eddin Ibrahim, the famed Egyptian reformer, and current visiting professor at Harvard University, spoke this morning at the foreign policy panel at the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC) annual convention.
He was optimistic that the Obama administration could work to empower reformers, despite indications that pro-democracy reform was not something the administration would be investing much in. His speech in Cairo sent that message, despite lip service to the need for reform.
Ibrahim said something pretty disturbing. In discussing the need to re-think the dichotomy between moderate regimes and radicals — a question put forward by the moderator, Yousef Munayyer, he said that the Arab “monarchies are more stable and more benevolent” than the radical secular regimes the leftist Arabs used to praise in the 1960s.
He said, “some of the old radicals are still in power.”
His examples? Qaddafi has 40 years in power, he pointed out. When was the last time leftist reformers held the Libyan leader in high regard?
He also mentioned Hosni Mubarak — hardly a leftist beacon.
Ibrahim made a humorous quip about Mubarak’s nearly 28 years of rule. After Ramses II and Muhammed Ali, Mubarak is the third longest ruler in 5000 years of history.
His assumption is because secular leaders have proven to be dictators that the monarchies are somehow preferable. That is an objectionable dichotomization, which was something he sought to re-think from the start. He should have condemned both. If he purely means it as a comparison, he should have qualified it in criticism of both.
After all, Arab monarchs stay in power for life and only run on hereditary succession. Plus, with the non-monarchs increasingly taking on similar succession patterns in Syria and Egypt, the dichotomy he suggests is contrived.
As a dissident who has faced punitive action by Mubarak, I respect him as a man of action. However, his praise of the monarchs, even if relative, is inexcusable.
Related posts:
- George Bush: The Saad Eddin Ibrahim of the United States
- Even When Arabs Vote…
- Laura Bush: Modern Egyptologist
- The Danger of Arab Bloggers
- Marwan Kraidy on Arab Media Charter
Good job., Buy Cialis Online, >:PPP, Cheap Cigarettes, xvrja, Buy Tramadol, 485, Buy Tramadol, 964, Cheap Valium, hoi,
Posted by Cheap Ativan | June 30, 2009, 3:47 amGood job., Cheap Valium, =-(, Cialis, 4934, Buy Viagra, 8-], Ultram, :OOO, Diazepam, :O,
Posted by Tramadol | June 30, 2009, 3:59 amI like your work!, Tamiflu online, iavqha, Buy Cialis Online, 93398, Buy Ativan, 759374, Buy Tramadol, 5958, Cheap Valium, 293,
Posted by Buy Tramadol | June 30, 2009, 4:46 amYour Site Is Great!, Cheap viagra, 999, cialis, >:-OOO, viagra, 97193, viagra
, >:[, Cheap Ativan, 245,
Posted by viagra | June 30, 2009, 5:14 amThank You!, Buy Phentermine, whmoy, Diazepam, 20219, Klonopin
, utd, Buy Ambien, 8-O, Cialis, mspo,
Posted by Buy Viagra | June 30, 2009, 6:37 amNise site., Phentermine, zdnusm, Buy Viagra online, 0190, viagra, xhczp, Buy Cigarettes, 8-(((, Cigarettes, 8P,
Posted by Buy Viagra | June 30, 2009, 6:42 amBest Wishes!, Clonazepam, jezyo, Cheap viagra, rxzk, Buy Ambien, >:))), Cheapest Cialis, vashp, Ativan, =P,
Posted by Ambien | June 30, 2009, 8:38 amYour Site Is Great!, Diazepam, zfxk, Cigarettes
, %-], Tramadol, 512790, Cialis, 459407, Ativan
, 8))),
Posted by Cheap Ambien | June 30, 2009, 9:14 amBest Wishes!, Buy Xanax,
((, Buy Ambien, jcf, Buy Tramadol, 
, Valium
, %-((, Buy Cialis Online, qhffrh,
Posted by Cialis | June 30, 2009, 9:24 amNise site., Ambien, =P, Buy Tamiflu, =O, Ativan, >:-DD, Tramadol
, 45257, Buy Viagra, efptrc,
Posted by Buy Klonopin | June 30, 2009, 9:38 amI like your work!, Cialis
, 8-], Phentermine
, garpou, Xanax
, 267, Valium, =-OO, Cheapest Cialis, %DD,
Posted by Buy Ambien | June 30, 2009, 10:07 amGood job., kamagra, gvw, Buy Ambien, jzjj, Cheap Ativan, njl, viagra, %[[[, Lorazepam, qnl,
Posted by Ultram | June 30, 2009, 10:13 amBest Wishes!, comprare cialis, 449, Buy Xanax, =]]], Marlboro Cigarettes, >:)), Buy Ativan,
(, Buy Viagra, 829,
Posted by Buy Ambien | June 30, 2009, 12:37 pmThank You!, Klonopin
(, Buy Ativan, 380, cialis kaufen, zqua, Cheapest Cialis, qsyjuz, Buy Cialis Online, tfr,
,
Posted by viagra | June 30, 2009, 12:45 pmGood job., Zolpidem, kicxpv, Buy Cigarettes, yfid, Viagra
, 759723, Phentermine, 6927, Ativan, rqauuw,
Posted by Ultram | June 30, 2009, 1:34 pmNise site., viagra kaufen, 8-))), Ambien
, cxjiz, Ativan
, busae, Buy Cialis Online, oymxy, Cheapest Cialis, keqdxa,
Posted by Cheap Klonopin | June 30, 2009, 1:34 pmGood job., kamagra en ligne, >:[[, Cheap Xanax, 8939, viagra en ligne, =PPP, Buy Tramadol, 91516, Viagra
, kcb,
Posted by Buy Cialis | June 30, 2009, 1:36 pmThank You!, Cheap Ambien, lxdej, Cheap Xanax, :], Buy Valium, ufczwz, Cheap Ambien, =-[[, Viagra, guwhvj,
Posted by Xanax | June 30, 2009, 2:23 pmI like your work!, kamagra kaufen, bbhhds, Klonopin
, 00149, Clonazepam, 0395, Cheap viagra, jscmu, viagra, 72733,
Posted by Cigarettes | June 30, 2009, 2:26 pmYour Site Is Great!, Cigarettes
, 6057, Ambien
, >:-(((, Tramadol, =PP, aquista kamagra, %-DDD, Buy Valium, 715558,
Posted by Alprazolam | June 30, 2009, 3:14 pmNise site., Cigarettes, ygc, Cialis
, 446054, Buy Tramadol, 8-]], Cigarettes
, mgp, Cialis, 0548,
Posted by Cheap kamagra | June 30, 2009, 3:19 pmGreat inputs here, love your blog.
Posted by invituido | August 27, 2009, 4:48 pmI think you made some good points in your post.
Posted by Sagsnuccusa | September 27, 2009, 4:36 amexcellent blog!!
you have really good information!
Katie
Posted by Viagra Onlina | September 28, 2009, 2:26 pmfuel http://board.muse.mu/member.php?u=126157
Posted by tomkincasc | October 9, 2009, 9:57 pmworking state http://board.muse.mu/member.php?u=126159
Posted by hugettecro | October 9, 2009, 10:03 pmallowed warm http://board.muse.mu/member.php?u=126153
Posted by kayiynaran | October 9, 2009, 10:07 pmNice and Helpful information. I really liked your article. I think the way you have described the matter is really interesting.
Posted by Health Information | November 12, 2009, 5:09 pm