// you're reading...

Egypt

A story that needs to be told

This is the quintessential Palestinian story. It illuminates the insanity of Israel’s dispossession and occupation of the Palestinians.

From Mohammad Alsaafin:

I’m writing to you as friends, colleagues, members of the media, acquaintances and activists. Some of have never met me; others have heard parts of the story I am about to tell. However, I do believe that all of you may have an interest in reading this – it is a story that needs to be told.

I am a Palestinian refugee, from the village of Fallujah which lies between Gaza, Hebron and Asqalan. I’ve never been allowed to visit Fallujah; my grandparents were exiled from there in 1949 (a year after the founding of Israel) and took refuge in the Gaza Strip. My father and I were both born in the Khan Younis refugee camp-he a few years before Gaza was occupied by Israel, and I a month after the outbreak of the first intifada. My dad married a woman from the West Bank-they had met and fallen in love while they were both studying at Birzeit University, and when I was two years old we emigrated to the UK where he received his Phd.

Fourteen years later, in 2004, we all returned to Palestine to live in Ramallah. Now British citizens, my parents were determined that my three siblings and I would forge a stronger connection to our homeland than we ever could living abroad. At first, the transition was made easier by the fact that our foreign passports gave us the freedom of movement that was denied to other Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza. For me, this reality was shattered when in late 2005 I attempted to cross the River Jordan from the West Bank to visit my aunt in Amman. The Israeli border agents told me that I could not pass, because I had an Israeli issued Gaza ID. Under Israeli military rules, this meant that I could not ‘legally’ be present in the West Bank because the Israeli occupation had mandated that Palestinians from Gaza could not enter the West Bank, and Palestinians from the West Bank could not enter Gaza. This policy had been in force since the early 1990′s, but was applied with increasing severity after the outbreak of the second intifada.

I lived the next four years under constant fear of arrest by the Israeli military, because that would have resulted in almost certain deportation to Gaza, and isolation from my family. For those four years, I never left the confines of Ramallah, so as to avoid the Israeli checkpoints on every one of the town’s entrances-but even this couldn’t give me a sense of security because I had to commute daily to Birzeit University, on a route frequently patrolled by Israeli forces from the nearby settlement of Bet El.

In July of this year, after many pleas for assistance from the hapless Palestinian Authority, I asked the Israeli NGO Gisha to help me obtain permission from the Israeli occupation to leave the West Bank. I wanted to take part in an internship in the United States, but I would only be granted the permission to exit on the condition that I only return to the Gaza Strip, which had been under siege and total closure for the better of two years then. I accepted this impossible choice-after four years of imprisonment in Ramallah, I wanted to see the outside world and look for a job abroad.

During this entire period, my family had more or less been saved the travel restrictions imposed on me. As a foreign journalist, my dad frequently traveled between the West Bank, Gaza and inside the Green Line, and my mother and siblings would join him on day trips to Jerusalem, Umm al-Fahem, Acca and Haifa. But that all changed this August when he was entering Gaza through the Erez crossing as he had done many times before. On this day however, he was arrested by the Israeli military and had his press credentials revoked. He was told his British passport was worthless, because they had made a frightening discovery: My dad had been born and raised in a refugee camp in Gaza, and had a Gaza ID. They told him he would henceforth be treated not as a foreigner, but as a Gazan-he was sent into Gaza and told he could never cross the Green Line or enter the West Bank again.

My mother and siblings back in Ramallah were also informed that their British passports were worthless and that they would be issued Palestinian IDs by Israel. Despite being raised in the West Bank and still owning a copy of her old West Bank ID, my mother was actually issued with a Gaza ID. We assume this is because she married a Gazan 22 years ago, but nobody has given us a clear answer. This has put her in the same quandary I was in for the last four years. She cannot leave Ramallah for fear of arrest and deportation to Gaza, away from her children, her sister’s and the young children of her recently deceased brother. This situation was compounded by another perplexing development; my brother and sisters, all of whom were born in the UK, and whose parents and older brother had been issued Gaza ID’s, were issued West Bank IDs.

My dad spent the last few months trying to get permission to go back to the West Bank to see his wife and kids-even for a day to pick up his clothes. But whether it was through the British consulate or Israeli NGO’s, the Israeli occupation was adamant that he would not be allowed out of Gaza, unless it was to be deported from Ben Gurion airport. Eventually, in order to save his job, he left Gaza when Egypt opened the Rafah crossing in early December.

Now, my father is in one country and I am in another, while my mother is trapped in the West Bank, unable to travel for fear of never being allowed back. Thankfully, my brother and sisters are able to cross into Jordan, where we may see each other, but our family has been torn apart and separated under the most arbitrary occupation laws imaginable. Despite the continued attempts of Israeli and Palestinian NGO’s, we have found no recourse with the Israeli authorities, and the British consulate has proved useless. We even sent a letter to Tony Blair, the representative of the Quartet, imploring him to intervene on our behalf as British citizens. Unsurprisingly, we were ignored, but I have attached a copy of that letter to this email.

I believe this story needs to be told not because our situation is so unique, but precisely because it isn’t; this is the result of a deliberate Israeli policy, one that has been in place since the early days of the Nakba and has been evolving ever since. It is a policy that has led to the dispossession of millions of Palestinians, and the separation and breakup of tens of thousands of families. The forcibly imposed separation between the West Bank and Gaza is illegal under international law, and through it Israel is succeeding in separating the Palestinian people, one family at a time.

I am hoping that some of you will be able to spread this story through any platform you have, whether it is amongst your own friends and acquaintances, on blogs or perhaps by helping this get picked up in the media. My mother fears that if this story does become publicly known, she will suffer the same fate as Berlanty Azzam, the Bethlehem University senior who was arrested by Israeli soldiers and deported to Gaza. Despite the publicity her case received, an Israeli court unabashedly maintained that a Gazan cannot study in a West Bank university. The risk is real, but we have no other choice.

Best wishes,

-Mohammad

Did you like this? Share it:

Related posts:

  1. Media Bulldoze Bulldozer Attack Story, Ignore Gaza’s Water Catastrophe
  2. Can’t even attend a funeral…
  3. Send a Zionist Organization Your Al-Nakba Story Today
  4. Man Bites Dog Palestine Coverage
  5. Captured Prisoners: The Full Story
Filed Under  ,

Discussion

8 Responses to “A story that needs to be told”

  1. Thank you Will for your intense, precise and living report on your family that the State of Israel have all splited. For what reason do they do this, other than you being non jews?

    Posted by lalacyrl | December 21, 2009, 11:28 pm
  2. Down with Israel.
    Justice shall be served.

    Posted by OooKhalid | December 22, 2009, 6:12 pm
  3. That story was painful to read on so many levels, but mostly, perhaps even selfishly so, because it struck so close to home, to my own family's story.
    My uncle, along with my father, left Jerusalem for education in the US in the 1970s. My cousin, Samer, and his sister were born in the states but at the age of six and seven were sent back home to Jerusalem to live with our grandparents until their parents were able to leave the US for good. When he was fourteen years old, living with his parents and siblings, Samer, along with with a bunch of neighborhood children, fatefully threw some stones at an Israeli trooper. Nobody was hurt, but a full-blow investigation took place and my cousin was sent to prison, he stayed their for a year, but unlike others who might have been released, my cousin was shipped off to the US. The Israeli authorities, upon discovering that he was a US citizen and had not yet obtained legal residency in Jerusalem (ie the blue card), chose to tear a teenage boy away from his family and boarded him on a direct flight to the US with nothing but the clothes on his back. Though I was very young I still remember meeting him at the airport with my parents when he arrived, a lost boy, with a white bag carrying all of his belongings. Samer's father immediately left Jerusalem and lived with his son, for years to come my uncle's family was ripped apart, but the emotional toll the ordeal had taken upon Samer was unknown to us at teh time. He spent years drifting from one place to the next, pining for his mother and siblings who, not once were able to visit him because they too could not leave Jerusalem for fear of never being allowed to reenter since they, despite having grown up in Jerusalem, did not have ID cards.

    Posted by Jerusalemite | December 23, 2009, 12:41 am
  4. Years later, after much legal effort, Samer was allowed to visit his family and was given a three month visa, he was elated, the sense of home that Jerusalem was to him had never abated despite all those years abroad. When the three months were up he tried unsuccessfully to stay for more, but he was denied reentry and shipped right back to the US. Though my cousin was happy to be with his parents and extended family, that happiness was shadowed by the fact that he didn't really belong in Jerusalem anymore or anywhere for that matter, he was broken, in so many ways, from his time in prison to the fifteen years he spent away from his family, away from his mother. Sometimes I wonder how a Jewish mother, known for doting on their sons, would feel if her child was stripped away from her forever, my aunt was and always will a deeply tormented woman, and now even more so. Samer died last summer, he had a heart attack, two in fact and is now buried in a US city, away from his true home, and from our grandfather's grave which shortly before his death, asked to be buried next to. Though my family mourned him as any would mourn their son, we didn't lose my cousin this summer, that already happened so years ago when, as a child, he was exiled from his land, from his family. Though all is lost and it makes no sense for Samer's story to be told, I wanted to nonetheless.

    Posted by Jerusalemite | December 23, 2009, 12:42 am
    • Please write up your story and send it to us and others. These stories need to be aggregated-they recieve a lot more attention than you'd think. Palestinians are so conditioned to live with the injustices Israel frces upon them that we keep silent, we live with it, instead of telling the world. Believe me, people want to hear that story.

      Posted by MohammadKF | December 24, 2009, 8:51 am
  5. Hello,thanks you for this wonderful blogg, i really find much

    Posted by Gerry Sachse | December 24, 2009, 12:12 pm
  6. Does anybody find much hypocrisy in the Arab blogosphere?
    http://iraqimojo.blogspot.com/2009/12/starbucks-i…

    Posted by Iraqi_Mojo | December 25, 2009, 7:33 pm
  7. I have a very active blog. This is by no means the worst story I would put up, to be very honest because I tend to go with the worst cases. My mate comes from Nablus and he has not been able to visit his mother for 20+ years now. He cannot even send her money.

    But I will post this because you ask so nicely and it IS just another facet of these awful people. I will be honest, they couldn't give a sweet Flack over your situation. Nor could Blair. To them you are just more creatures unworthy to live on the planet.

    I will have to find some suitable illustrations but I will post this along with the credit line immediately.

    Posted by NooR | January 6, 2010, 5:39 pm

Post a comment

Connect With Us Ya Hmeer!

resume resume

Recent Posts

3la Aysh Sufayt?: A Sovereign Palestinian State
January 30, 2012
By Husam
Let’s Kill Obama! (And the Subsequent Fracas)
January 27, 2012
By Yazan
Saleh Gone: What Next?
January 26, 2012
By Abubakr
Kuwaiti Youth Are Stuffed Goats
January 25, 2012
By Guest
Logik Politik
January 24, 2012
By Guest
Inshallah, Kashmir
January 19, 2012
By Sana
The Hypocrisy on Palestine
January 19, 2012
By Guest
Let’s Talk About Sectarianism, Baby
January 18, 2012
By Abubakr
Diary of a Bad Man
January 17, 2012
By Nabeelah
In Defense of Resistance: Hezbollah and the Syrian Intifada
January 16, 2012
By Yazan
America’s Most Lethal Navy SEAL Sniper
January 12, 2012
By OmarS
Israel: South Sudan’s Big Brother
January 11, 2012
By Nabeelah
Not Just Decor: The Struggle for Real Women’s Rights in Lebanon
January 10, 2012
By Guest
Don’t Ignore Ron Paul
January 9, 2012
By OmarS
History of US Intervention in Iran
January 6, 2012
By Sana