Like many organizations Hamas is not a one unified group and it seldom speaks with one voice. In Gaza, there are few reasonable men and women who are in leadership positions in Hamas Gaza government. Those Hamas leaders, many educated in the West have no military background and that’s why many in the international community do not mind working with them. However, since those leaders have no militant connection, they are often weak in the ranks of Hamas and its decisions making. The bands of tugs and militant groups that is commissioned with protecting the establishment of Hamas and its leaders are the dangerous one. Most Hamas militants do not mind breaking into people’s homes and even kill individuals of interest. As long as you are away from the Radar of those Hamas militants, you are safe.
The reasonable and educated Hamas leaders often has no leverage with those groups, as the militants only answer to the Hamas leader in Damascus. I have seen countless graphic images of Hamas brutality against individuals in Gaza. Having spoken of Hamas’ brutality does not take away the few dozen of accomplishments that Hamas government has put in place. Anyone visiting Gaza will feel that with the entire negative image Hamas has, they remain defiant and strive to govern and to improve life in Gaza. Here are ten accomplishments Hamas working against many odds, has delivered to the people of Gaza.
1. Traffic in Gaza is better managed since the Hamas police force gives people the appearance of toughness and willingness to do anything to enforce the law. Drivers and cabbies now respect the traffic laws. They complain too much, but the city is a lot easier to navigate for pedestrians and drivers under the control of the bearded officers. It’s true they have few random control checkpoints here and there and guns on every corner, but the fruits of their labor are enjoyed by all Palestinians in Gaza. This often the reason Hamas supporters share to credit the Hamas government.
2. Markets are better organized. Trying to go to the market before was at your own risk–too many vendors, crowded and narrow streets, constant fights between street vendors…chaos. Hamas police forces took control of the markets and anyone who does not obey the law, they beat them up on the spot. They made examples of a few vendors and since then everybody does what they are told. Under the previous administration, if a policeman roughed up a guy for violating the law, then the guy could get his family to beat up the officer and no one would care. Try beating up a Hamas officer and see if anyone will ever find you.
3. In Gaza large families who intimidate others have been broken and subdued. In the past, and during Fatah control of Gaza, large clans in Gaza bragged about how many weapons and ammo they could get ready if a fight broke out with a member of their clan. In other words, those few families even intimidated the government. Hamas said, “We are not going to take this!” In the first faceoff with those clans, Hamas threw whatever guns and man power they had to break the will of those clans and they did just that. Since most leaders in Hamas come from small families, the assault on large clans makes sense. Now size no longer matters in Gaza. Said Syyam, the former Hamas Minister of Interior successfully spearheaded this front.
4. Dubious financial transactions and frauds are kept to a minimum. As my dad and siblings own several businesses in Gaza, I can tell you that in the past people can write you a check with no credit and once the check bounced, you weren’t able to collect your money because they legal system did not enforce the law it made. Hamas now says if anyone of those guys does not pay you the money, come to us and we will make sure you get your money. My dad tells me that if he takes a returned check to the proper authorities, the first thing they will do is put the person who issued the check in jail for 21 days. It gets worse after that.
5. Debt collection is easier under the new government. Dad tells me that if a member of the Hamas government does not pay when he says he will pay and dad files a complaint against him/her then the government will garnish the debtor’s paycheck and pay the debt collector right away. If the person is not affiliated with the government, the Hamas guys will call him and ask him to pay. If he does not pay, they ask him to come in. By then most people pay up. Dad brags about how he uses this service regularly. He says most people who like to be seen with Hamas guys are afraid of being punished by Ramallah government who fires and cuts the salaries of any employee of theirs who has contact or has been perceived as such dad does not mind it as he is retired and frequently disses Hamas.
6. Taxi services function 24/7 due to the increased security. This is the one service I enjoy the most in Gaza. Taxi offices are spread all over the narrow Strip. Now we can spend all day and night on the beach or visiting family and know that we can get a ride anytime. This service would not flourish if the sense of security and safety did not exist. Under the previous government, this taxi service late at night was not an option. Random gunmen were seen throughout the night and fear was all around.
7. Random killing is kept to minimum because any unauthorized use of firearms is investigated and punished. In the late years of the previous government, Gaza was a replica of the Wild Wild West. People get killed for no reason and no one knows who fired. People used to lose their lives for being in the wrong places the wrong time or for just being themselves. Nowadays, every time one uses a gun, it gets reported to the police who take it seriously (I suppose Hamas does not want Fatah guys carrying firearms). If you shoot a gun you better be a policeman or have a compelling reason for doing so. The only people who have arms other than the police are the Palestinian resistance groups–mainly Islamic Jihad.
8. The Gaza beach is now a place where families can actually enjoy themselves, as opposed to the past where a few jerks harassed any female that went into the water. It used to bother me to see young men changing their clothes in public in front of kids and women. This is no longer a major problem. For example, I swam last summer with my fiancé and no one harassed us–maybe because it was dark. In the past we would have more personal freedom, but that also means others would have had more personal freedom to harass us–mainly her. Now, anytime you complain of the improper conduct of the youngsters, they take it seriously. To be honest, we had to take our IDs and rings in case an extremist element of Hamas wanted to make sure we are Halal.
9. Hamas has done a better job in embracing technology in governing. In Gaza, many government services can be done online. No need to stand in a long line, eliminating the uncertainty and promoting transparency. There are few government services that can be delivered to cellphones to save people the commute where limited gas is a problem. It seems that smaller groups are quicker to embrace new technologies. That perhaps explains why Hamas has a superior and an extensive media arm than Fatah.
10. Favoritism is kept to minimum, or so it seams… Gaza is like the rest of Palestine and like the rest of the third world. An area where people count on friends and relatives to push their case on their behalf. Hamas has managed to stay above the fray by simply ignoring requests to play favorites. Obviously not all Hamas officials are saints, there is abuse, but anytime an abuse is reported people lose their jobs. I think this is largely due to religious convictions and to a lesser extent Hamas’ intentions to be different than Fatah. I had a young Fatah activist tell me about Fatah “In the past, they used hire women who do not have many work related experiences”, “they only need to show some cleavage and legs and they are hired Manager C level”, “Now, this does not fly with them” This is true to a certain degree, but I think now a mosque connection can help get you a job with Hamas.
To be fair, those accomplishments do much to make life better in Gaza, however, they do little to ease the brutal siege placed on Gaza. Hamas remains unable to govern effectively because they fail to secure food supplies for their population, and worse they feel to secure freedom of movement for an entire people. Weather Hamas agrees to form a unity government or not, this has to be seen in the next few weeks For now, I am hoping the people of Gaza will finally see a light at the end of the tunnel, pun intended.
Related posts:
- The Gaza Memos: Unity Agreement?
- Israel, Not Hamas, Bans Music in Gaza
- Post-Gaza Palestinians Worse Off, but Not Blaming Hamas
- At the Ballot Box, Trouble is Brewing for Hamas
- The Gaza Experience: Women on Bikes…Now She Can’t















Ah, the yearn for the strong man.
One can get a feeling reading your post why democracy is having problems in the Arab world.
Someone owes you money? Why bother going through the courts if a Hamas thug can intimidate him.
So convenient these strong man regimes.
Someone disobeys the law? The police get to beat him up on the stop. Who needs a court of law?
Oh, I wish we had that in the US. How great that would be.
The irony is that you don't even comprehend how basically anti-democratic your tendencies are. I am not saying that Hamas actions have not improved things. But when someone really embraces democracy, he knows to distinguish between the short term gains achieved by Mafia like organizations in establishing "order" and the long term struggle for rule of law. And it seems that you like the Arab world in general are sacrificing the latter for the former. A very bad choice indeed.
Posted by jjj | January 27, 2010, 5:39 pm"Someone owes you money? Why bother going through the courts if a Hamas thug can intimidate him. "
You seem to have not read the post you are critiquing.
Anyway, I think you Hanitizer may have offered praise to Hamas which is better owed to Hobbes' Leviathan, rather than Hamas per se.
Hamas might have the ties and connections to operate as a state in Gaza but its not much of a substitute for the effective institutions of a state. Unless Hamas can make separate these achievements from its own party and social machine, i.e. create a state another democratically elected executive could run, then I'm not sure its worth crediting Hamas with much of an achievement.
Posted by Left Outside | January 27, 2010, 9:59 pmWhen the rule of law fails the Arab street over and over again it's not too strange to see the allure of the strongman.
Fatah had years controlling the PA to institute some semblance of law and a functioning court order but didn't. Iraq and Afghanistan are currently enjoying weak, corrupt and ineffective democracies that border on collapsing. Kuwait, the GCC member with the most democratic system of government (relatively speaking of course) is paralyzed while more autocratic regimes like Saudi Arabia, Abu Dhabi and Qatar continue to flourish.
Democracy is all well and good but if it doesn't make your life better than most see no reason to sacrifice their lives and livelihoods to see it consumed by politicians.
Posted by Mohamed S. | January 28, 2010, 3:22 pmI do not understand your answer. Are you against trying democracy in the Arab world?
Do you expect democracy to work perfectly immediately?
Do you think dictators are the right choice for the Arab world?
Posted by jjj | January 29, 2010, 2:37 amthe people that commented seem to forget that Gaza is one big war zone and it has run amock (sp) adn needs to be controlled any way possible until food and med supplies can be secured….its sad to see this happeneing but hey whatever works to steer away chaos is fine with me cuz I was there and even without Israel invasions it was scary to be in a place where even the govt couldnt control its people….besides what they do desnt even come close to what america is doing in Iraq and afghanistan to control order!
Posted by sarah | January 27, 2010, 11:18 pmThe typical Arab response:
1) 1000 years of tyranny are better than one day of anarchy. (Are you happy with your 1000 years of tyranny?)
2) Other are doing worse. The old 2 wrongs make a right argument. Oh, by the way, Israel is acting in Gaza much better than Sudan in Darfur, therefore what Israel does is ok. No?
Pathetic.
Posted by jjj | January 28, 2010, 1:35 am“The typical Arab response:”
And that would be the typical racist response. Perhaps you can tell us about typical black responses and typical Latino responses and typical Jewish responses too?
Posted by Non-Arab Arab | January 28, 2010, 2:34 pmNo, a racist response would be "All Arabs would respond the following".
From what I have read, typically Arabs answer as I wrote. Not all, but it is the typical answer.
Posted by jjj | January 29, 2010, 2:32 amjjj, I wish Arabs were as united as you take them to be…If Arabs thing the same, then we won't have internal problems in Palestine, Lebanon and Iraq. Democracy is good, but if democracy in Arab country undermined the interest of a major player, then the people of that country are screwed.
Posted by Hanitizer | January 29, 2010, 2:31 pmWell… Hamas won the elections fair and square, right? So, that makes them legitimate government, and governments use force to impose law and order. That's how it works, I think?
Posted by erv | February 6, 2010, 1:45 amright. and the people who voted for hamas have to accept the consequences. by the way, hamas is against having elections now because the people seem to want to vote them out.
Posted by perv | February 6, 2010, 2:18 am"hamas is against having elections now because the people seem to want to vote them out"
ok .. thats not true ..
actually there is a million things written here is away from truth ..
Thanks for western media whose telling you lies lies lies every day ..
Don't forget .. Gaza under blockade no water no food no electricity no gas it's war at it's exterme face .. imagine if this happens to any western city .. it would be like tom cruise "war at world" movie … you will not believe
Unfortunately Hamas is the good guy here and isreal is the bad guy … and that what makes the equation goes wrong this time
Rethink about it please ..
Posted by Arabian Bastard | July 28, 2010, 10:07 pmthe movie is : War of the Worlds*
Posted by Arabian Bastard | July 28, 2010, 10:10 pmhiiii, you’re gay
k bye !
Posted by Ppenis. | September 1, 2010, 7:25 amola ich sage dir wie cool die palästinenser sind ich bin eine
Posted by sarah | December 9, 2011, 1:54 pm