// you're reading...


Book Review: Rula Jebreal’s Miral

This post was originally written for Muslimah Media Watch. This version, however, includes a brief discussion on the depiction and portrayal of Palestinian resistance in the novel.

Miral, a novel written by Rula Jebreal and made into a film by American filmmaker Julian Schnabel, is the story of a young girl’s coming of age–physically, emotionally and politically–in a Jerusalem of the 1980s, which finds itself smothered with student demonstrations, violent resistance, and unrelenting occupation alongside everyday uncharted life.

After the tragic death of their mother, Miral and her younger sister, Rania, are put in Hind Husseini’s school for young girls. The girls visit their father, an imam at al-Aqsa, as well as spend their summers with him. The school becomes a second home for the young girls as they find themselves trying to deal with the seemingly worsening political situation in the Occupied Territories and also with life’s daily hurdles and occasional struggles.

Miral becomes increasingly involved with the political resistance, particularly the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, much to the dismay and worry of her family and her school. Her impulsive nature, immature experience and resounding passion for her people put herself, her family, and the her fellow students in constant danger. Ultimately, Miral is forced to make a decision having to choose between joining the resistance movement and continuing her education. She pursues studies to use her mind and ability as forms of resistance– to be, as Husseini says to Miral, “future women leaders of Palestine, not martyrs.”

Despite some memorable characters and moments, as well as the (ultimately brief) acknowledgment of Hind Husseini’s work and life, the books fails to be anything more than, as the Omar El-Khairy notes in a review of the film, “Palestine as Hollywood fantasy.” While the film is markedly different from the novel in many ways, El-Khairy’s critiques remain as relevant as for the book as they do for the movie. The book is written to be a film seemingly more about sexually adventurous, politically aggressive and unorthodox Palestinian Muslim women who stand against the almost invariably abusive, rigidly-traditional minded men who try to exert certain sort control over the various women in the novel, as opposed to a novel about the Palestinian experience, during the volatile period of the Intifada, especially for young women.

The novel is filled with weak and forced metaphors, poor writing and a severe lack of flow in narration, lucidly highlighting the author’s personal political beliefs and agenda, deeply drenched in an exoticized Western perception of Arab women. There is belly dancing, there is a lot of guilt-ridden sex, and there is the use of the words “exotic Middle Eastern features.”

There is also no organization and no sense of time as well. The book begins in 1948 Palestine, jumping back and forth between the beginning of the Oslo period and the Nakba, finally settling into the ‘80s, during which most of Miral’s life and story develops. Yet while the stories of different women “strangely” connected by fate and challenges they’ve faced in their lives (coming mostly from men) relate heavily to Miral, they ultimately play very little relevance in the development of the plot and Miral’s character.  In fact, many characters fall flat in their development, primarily due to Jebreal’s ‘on-the-nose’ and rushed style of writing, which leaves very little to the reader’s imagination. Intimate moments and otherwise momentous self-awareness occasions are reduced to obvious statements made by Jebreal. For instance, in the scene where Miral and Rania spend their first few nights in the new school, all the other girls – orphans, abandoned in one form or another – push their beds together and hold onto one another tightly, at night, just before falling asleep.

This particular scene is described warmly by Jebreal and set up for the readers in the previous chapters, which described the backgrounds of the school, its founders and the various girls staying there. The instance of intimacy shared between these girls beautifully and wrenchingly highlights the loss and feelings of loneliness as a result of their collective and individual abandonment, most apparent at night in those moments before falling asleep.

Yet rather than allowing the reader to discern his/her own meaning from this intimate moment, as predicated by the author previously, Jerbreal ends the scene by letting the audience know that “[s]uch gestures of affection were means of compensating for the lack of physical contact with their mothers” and thus in effect kind of ruining that sweet moment of intimacy.

The on-the-nose writing is also heavily apparent throughout the dialogue in the book, particularly that pertaining to the nature of political resistance and general politics; certain characters early on establish that the best form of resistance is education, a theme which continues throughout the book. While agreeable, Jebreal’s treatment of Palestinian resistance-beyond education and in the context of the Intifada-was ultimately reduced merely to irrational, impassioned violence although sometimes understandable for young testosterone-heavy Kanafani-esque refugee boys.
While clear that Jebreal is familiar with the work of Ghassan Kanafani, she fails to bring in the spirit of the writer’s work, particularly post-1967,  into her own portrayal of Palestinian resistance. Reading Kanafani’s work makes the intellectual and political shift in resistance comprehensible. Taking up arms was not meant to be a sort of senseless violence based on a thirst for vengeance, as Jebreal seems to allude to at times, but rather an act meant to take back the cause from the hands of outside Arab governments into the hands of the Palestinians themselves. Despite personal convictions, it needs to be accepted that Palestinian resistance (much like any other political resistance), particularly that which employs the use of violence, has context, has history and has even an intellectual, strategic foundation. To reduce it simply to passion, immaturity, a lack of clarity and a complete unconscious devotion to blind faith in the return to the Palestine pre-Nakba lacks any real portrayal of the Palestinian experience.

Finally, there is the overall portrayal of women, sex and general gender in the novel. There is nothing more evident of the audience to whom Jebreal is writing than when she is discussing the various, dispersed female characters, both those who are seemingly integral to the story and those who are in passing. They are all sexually “expressive” women, breaking the shackles of tradition, feeling little to no guilt, reclaiming their womanhood from men who’ve tried their hardest to exert some sort of abusive or ideological control on their lives. As El-Kheiry notes in his review, “[a]part from the benign figure of Jamal, Palestinian men spend their time raping, drooling over or marrying off their daughters.” And women are either weak and subservient or defying tradition, asserting their independence and strength by never getting married and becoming in some sense, “masculated” themselves. There’s even an instant of lesbian sexual experiment as well as young girls demanding Middle Eastern-looking Barbies, in contrast to the blonde-haired blue-eyed voluptuous devils to which the rest of us are accustomed.

Hind Husseini, based off of a real woman by the same name, was perhaps the most intriguing character in the novel, given her very real existence and integral place in Palestinian history, particularly immediately following the Nakba. Had the story circulated around her, as opposed to taking several detours and tangents before deciding to focus on Miral, there could have been great potential for this novel to have a place in a long list of books about the varying Palestinian experience.

Instead, poor writing and blunt ideological rants expressed through various characters render this book as only a vehicle for the big screen, with an ending to match. My suggestion? Read Gate of the Sun or The Yacoubian Building. It will have been time much better spent.

Filed Under  , , , , , , , ,


22 Responses to “Book Review: Rula Jebreal’s Miral”

  1. Book Review: Rula Jebreal’s Miral | KABOBfest Will you be writing more about this particular subject.

    Posted by Bail Bonds La Mirada | January 20, 2011, 11:42 pm
  2. this is a tuft of gigantic data recognition you

    Posted by Sachiko Bodelson | January 21, 2011, 8:44 pm
  3. Thank you. You have save a lot of my valuable time; because now i will not attempt to read the book, let aloe watch the movie!

    Posted by OooKhalid | January 22, 2011, 7:20 am
  4. I wish I read this review before waisting my time on this book.

    Posted by A. Samara | June 18, 2011, 9:49 pm
  5. The language of commerce and yes those who know English will go ahead of those who don't. I agree that Urdu should be the first language.

    Posted by thesis | June 24, 2013, 6:22 pm
  6. The review of the book named Miral by Rula Jabreal was very interesting. I am much interesting in reading. I love reading books based on facts. Can I order this book online? Please reply me as soon as possible.

    Posted by more here | July 15, 2013, 7:12 am
  7. Actually it’s a so fair article. it has draw in me so much. you can contact our professional custom essay writing help which will help with writing your paper. just carry on ………

    Posted by Maccullam | July 20, 2013, 10:41 pm
  8. This is a great history. It is really written in a good and healthy way, hope that you can create more essay and research paper here. Thank you for sharing this post.

    Posted by essays | September 17, 2013, 5:38 am
  9. I give full reviews to that book

    Posted by Boarding School | September 27, 2013, 10:33 am
  10. i give full reviews to your book

    Posted by Boarding School | September 27, 2013, 12:48 pm
  11. I give 5 rating out of 5 to Rula Jebreal’s Miral book

    Posted by moving to costa rica | October 6, 2013, 5:26 pm
  12. Roopons is Offering a 90 Day, No Obligation FREE Trial Roopons is an Effective Mobile and Social Marketing Tool FREE …
    Australia’s first QR mobile coupons app Using Roopons is as simple as 1, 2, 3. 1. Select a Roopon category & Search your …
    Mobile deals

    Posted by Mobile deals | October 26, 2013, 9:34 pm
  13. We provide Fast Funding up to 250,000 for Merchant Cash Advances and Business Cash Advances Easy 4 Step Process and 24 hour Approval Time.
    what is a merchant cash advance

    Posted by mk97442 | November 28, 2013, 1:14 am
  14. This book has really inspired me alot very nice book. SEO Manchester

    Posted by SEO Manchester | December 9, 2013, 5:47 am
  15. I think this is a very sensible review for particular book and clearly written other aspects.
    Dissertation Writing Help UK

    Posted by Stuart Jane | January 29, 2014, 1:45 pm
  16. It is delightful to read your article and you give us many important point on tourism. I am waiting for your next post.

    Posted by Ali Raza | August 1, 2014, 3:13 pm
  17. review of the book named Miral by Rula Jabreal was very interesting. I am much interesting in reading. I love reading books based on facts top 10 resume writers

    Posted by adam | November 23, 2014, 7:18 am
  18. Actually it’s a so fair article. it has draw in me so much. you can contact our professional custom essay writing help which will help with writing your paper

    Posted by writing essay tips | December 22, 2014, 12:10 pm
  19. The instance of intimacy shared between these girls beautifully and wrenchingly highlights the loss and feeling of them. We must protect them.

    Posted by wp services | September 19, 2015, 2:22 pm
  20. Writing and reading are very important and foundation of the entire and complete success of the education and studies. If the student and human have no idea of the reading skills and capacities, he cannot become good and effective writer.

    Posted by essay uk | October 3, 2015, 4:31 am

Post a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Recent Posts

question mark
Ever wonder what Bashar Al-Trump would look like?
December 17, 2015
By Guest
[John Locher / AP]
Top 5 Missing Things: The GOP Debate
December 16, 2015
By Guest
Jesus, Jesus was hot.
What Jesus Really Looked Like
December 15, 2015
By Guest
Israeli pigs
Zionist Pigs… Literally
December 14, 2015
By Guest
Worst New Syrian Tax Ever
December 11, 2015
By Guest
hate crime
Possibly the Most American Hate Crime of All Time
December 10, 2015
By Guest
What Anti-Muslim Rhetoric is Missing: Reality
March 23, 2015
By admin
Assad - Syrian Monster2
Oh the Horror of the Syrian Regime…
September 25, 2012
By Nabil
So, Who’s the Threat to America Again?
August 20, 2012
By Guest
So where do we keep Islamophobia?
Where Do We Keep Islamophobia?
August 15, 2012
By Shubnum
 Source: http://bilgrimage.blogspot.com/2011/12/usccb-political-lobbyists-or-advocates.html
Lobbying Versus Advocacy
August 1, 2012
By Mehrunisa
Jesus Is Alive At Speaker's Corner
On the destruction of Speaker’s Corner
July 17, 2012
By Abubakr
Picture 1
Stateless & Speechless, A Palestinian Regains Speech
July 12, 2012
By Hanitizer
Tyrone in a position of traditional Black prayer
White, Black American groups ‘swap’ summer interns
July 10, 2012
By Guest
The Costs of Stripping
June 25, 2012
By Mehrunisa