// you're reading...

Culture

Dictatorships Are No Longer in Vogue

Written originally for Muslimah Media Watch.

What does one of the world’s premier fashion and culture magazines have in common with one of the world’s most relentlessly brutal dictators?

A love for Asma al-Assad.

In the recent issue of Vogue, writer Joan Juliet Buck profiles Syrian president Bashar al-Assad’s charming, educated, eloquent and fashionable wife for her February 2011 piece “Rose in a Desert.” While renowned for exceptional aesthetic preferences, it is apparent that the magazine decided to let good taste take a backseat amidst a period of great tumult and bloodshed in the Middle East.

During the course of the past two months, a wave of anti-authoritarian uprisings have swept the Arab world, bearing witness to the masses of young Egyptians, Tunisians, Bahrainis, and Libyans risking life and limb for freedom from decades-long tyranny. While significant blows have been delivered to autocratic regimes and police states, revolutionary action has thus far failed to even nudge the Arab Republic of Syria, one of the region’s most repressive police states.

Rather than focusing on Syrian women rightly accorded the attribute of courage, Vogue chooses to gloss over Syrian authoritarianism and human rights abuses while simultaneously normalizing Asma al-Assad as nothing more than an everyday power-woman.

Asma al-Assad becomes a taunting enigma as we try to place her. Her marriage to a dictator, part of a brutally repressive regime with an equally unnerving history, is seemingly pushed to the side as a laughable circumstance of life, creating convenience for a discussion on how in-charge Asma is, how she gives back to her society, deals with whatever politics emerge in her life – all while looking flawlessly en vogue.

Yet despite the enigmatic portrayal, she is “normal” and “down to earth.” Early on in the piece, Asma notes that while growing up – as a daughter of a cardiologist and diplomat – she had to convince her friends that Syria was “normal” and that when she would show them photos from her summer trips back, they would be stunned at the images before them, unable to reconcile what lay before them and what they had heard about the country. Vogue fails to mention the privileges of Syrian life afforded to Mrs. Al-Assad by virtue of coming from an elite family, in stark contrast to millions of Syrians living a completely other reality.

How completely disassociated the First Lady remains from the reality of Syria is further highlighted when she discusses her goals for the country:

The 35-year-old first lady’s central mission is to change the mind-set of six million Syrians under eighteen, encourage them to engage in what she calls “active citizenship.” “It’s about everyone taking shared responsibility in moving this country forward, about empowerment in a civil society. We all have a stake in this country; it will be what we make it.”

Says the wife of a dictator part and parcel of a ruthless regime that has done nothing but voraciously repress all aspects of civil society for its entire existence. Instead, the fashion and culture magazine fail to mention the irony – which remains prevalent throughout the piece- and move on to give readers examples of the work she’s doing to promote “civil society” through NGOs.

Vogue also doesn’t shy away from, again without any sense of irony, showing the regime’s PR tactics abroad with the use of the lovely, cream-complexioned and blonde-haired First Lady, whose diplomatic efforts abroad to promote Syria as a beacon of culture and tolerance elicit undeserved reactions that see her as having “managed to get people to consider the possibilities of a country that’s modernizing itself, that stands for a tolerant secularism in a powder-keg region, with extremists and radicals pushing in from all sides…”

Rather than focusing on the extremism of the regime – against its own citizenry, against people of faith – again the focus is brought on how the country is apparently modernizing from an economic and image standpoint, while the archaic core of authoritarianism and lack of freedoms and rights remains virtually untouched.

Asma al-Assad is fascinating because she seems to be a Muslim Arab woman who doesn’t belong in the Muslim Arab world. She embodies the strong, self-assured, passionate White woman who is internally embattled; living in a society so seemingly ghastly antithetical to what she needs, or rather, even what she deserves. Yet despite this, her compassion as a woman and her Western-accorded sense of independence and abrasiveness have allowed her to help save her society at the most micro level, even if she chose to marry into a family infamous for indiscriminately killing almost 30,000 citizens of the state in an attempt to quell political dissidence.

Yet the glossing of history and reality remains within Vogue’s constructed narrative of the rose-like nature of not only Asma, a mark of beauty and life in a barren and brutal landscape, but also by extension, presumably, of Syria. If it is her face Vogue wishes to bring focus on, then it is her face that becomes Syria.

And let’s not pretend that Vogue’s concealment of Syria’s political and social realities is innocent or innocuous. After all, Vogue is America’s self-professed “cultural barometer,” an organization dedicated to women’s cultural empowerment. Per its mission statement:

Vogue’s story is the story of women, of culture, of what is worth knowing and seeing, of individuality and grace, and of the steady power of earned influence. For millions of women each month, Vogue is the eye of the culture, inspiring and challenging them to see things differently, in both themselves and the world.

If Vogue were to be interested in profiling ‘individuality and grace’ – particularly in Syria, a society whose 58.3% gender gap in employment trumps even that of Saudi Arabia – it had plenty of more deserving Syrian women to choose from. We have decided to suggest the Vogue editorial staff a few more suitable candidates for their next issue, free of charge.

Vogue’s readership would certainly be challenged to “see things differently, in both themselves and the world” if they heard the story of Tal al-Malouhi. At 20, this fashionable young Syrian student and blogger from the city of Homs has the distinction of being the world’s youngest prisoner of conscience, having recently been sentenced to five years in prison for “disclosing information to a foreign country that must remain a secret for national safety.” Prompting international condemnation and support from around the world, Tal is the epitome of the power of earned influence.

Or how about the “earned influence” of Syrian activist and political reformer Suhair Attasi? A longtime activist for progressive change in Syria, imprisoned and tortured for her purportedly subversive activity, this 37-year-old single mother unhesitatingly presses on, amidst the threats on her life: “If each one of us only thinks of his or her life,” she valiantly proclaimed, “then who would care about the future? My work is to bring about a better future for you, for me and for all of society.

Tal al-Malouhi and Suhair Attasi are are just two of several women whose stories are “worth knowing and seeing,” particularly for the role they have played in continued dissent in the face of an undemocratic regime that has worked tirelessly to remove any evident opposition, especially in the form of a civil society. Women, regardless of their geographic location of ethnic and religious affiliation, have played and continue to play an integral and prominent role in the fight for freedom, for reform and for a better life for all members of society. Vogue’s blatant disregard of these contributions for something more glamorous hurts, even at the piece’s most ironic moment when Asma al-Assad boasts of the “wildly democratic principles” that run and are promoted in her household, unaware of the juxtaposed hypocrisy that grips her words with the realities of day-to-day life for millions of Syrians.

And to think: a fashion magazine has never been so passé.

Did you like this? Share it:
Filed Under  , , , , ,

Discussion

10 Responses to “Dictatorships Are No Longer in Vogue”

  1. An analysis of a plugged PR piece in a semi-porn magazine that caters to women with emotional disorders (like low self-esteem and bulimia and some homosexual men with similar issues) is disappointing at a time when Arab women are part of the biggest movement in Middle East in decades. And why is an emotionally disordered Westerner's accurate perception of reality in the Middle East so important? In my opinion, you just gave a semi-porn magazine and a dictator's wife more importance than they deserve by writing a whole piece on them.

    Posted by sms | March 17, 2011, 5:51 pm
    • Vogue is one of the most highly-held magazines among women today – I am not saying its content is not semi-porn, but it does represent the voice of the modern female somewhat. But I do hate it when Westerners stereotype others in this way: if you don't act like one of them, you're just a barbarian from some remote place that they don't give a damn about.

      (Seriously, how many American Vogue readers can even point to Syria correctly on the map?)

      Posted by Josephine | March 17, 2011, 6:04 pm
    • My apologies, sir/madam. Never again shall I speak unless spoken to.

      Posted by SanaKF | March 17, 2011, 10:28 pm
  2. Josephine, which women are you speaking about? Anna Wintour is just another dictator if you read "The Devil Wears Prada" or any other expose on her (don't all dictators kiss each others' asses). Sure, many men read Playboy but does anyone take it seriously besides its subscribers?
    And Sana, I apologize if you felt like I was trying to silence you, I just wanted to make a couple of points a) Vogue is not taken seriously by anyone with a brain. b) most of Vogue's pieces are plugs c) the WASP or even the American perception of the Arab world no longer has a bearing on its reality d) the protests on Syria merit more coverage e) you just allowed a crap magazine to determine your agenda.

    Posted by sms | March 18, 2011, 3:06 am
  3. Dissing Vogue? The same author who posted the following a while back? Seriously? hypocrite much?
    http://www.kabobfest.com/2009/05/queenrania-asma-

    “But it doesn’t end there. What I respect perhaps the most about Asma al-Assad are her efforts to better the lives of Syrians through economic and technological development. While she keeps a relatively low profile, she’s an extremely involved member of her society. She’s the founder of an NGO (although, is it really an NGO if she’s the founder? Think about it) known as the Fund for Integrated Rural Development in Syria also known as F.I.R.D.O.S. Thus, rather than focusing solely only on the importance of diplomatic finesse between two wrongly constructed civilizational faultlines, she has recognized that within her country there are problems which need to be not only addressed but worked upon; viable solutions must be found. She not only recognizes the importance of independent and sustainable economic development in Syrian villages and rural towns but also of the immediate importance of computer technology (she’s apparently qualified in computer science). Additionally, within her economic development activism, she has focused on the role of women in rural development and the role of women in commerce. Makes sense given that this First Lady’s previous job was as a J.P Morgan investment banker.

    Ugh. So hot.”

    Posted by L.C. | April 2, 2011, 11:42 pm
  4. good…. enough said.

    Posted by foodstronmonsve | August 26, 2012, 2:49 pm
  5. Crossing Republic, Projects, Flats
    This One Crossing Republic Flats Vision has brought the top seven real estate groups together to create Crossings Republic Projects – India’s first global city.
    Keywords:-
    Crossing Republic, Crossing Republic Projects, Crossing Republic Flats
    CORPORATE OFFICE
    AMANDEEP INFRAHOME PVT. LTD
    B-85, Sector-63, Noida, U.P
    Tel: 0120-4330125, 0120-4330126, 0120-4330127
    Mobile: 91-8527702677 http://amanheights.co.in/crossing-republic-projec

    Posted by Shelly | February 15, 2013, 8:48 am

Post a comment

Connect With Us Ya Hmeer!

resume resume

Recent Posts

So, Who’s the Threat to America Again?
August 20, 2012
By Guest
Where Do We Keep Islamophobia?
August 15, 2012
By Shubnum
Lobbying Versus Advocacy
August 1, 2012
By Mehrunisa
On the destruction of Speaker’s Corner
July 17, 2012
By Abubakr
Stateless & Speechless, A Palestinian Regains Speech
July 12, 2012
By Hanitizer
White, Black American groups ‘swap’ summer interns
July 10, 2012
By Guest
The Costs of Stripping
June 25, 2012
By Mehrunisa
Be The Fundamental Pizza of a Man
June 25, 2012
By Guest
In US, They Want Fun, Fun Fun
June 23, 2012
By Sana
I Ain’t Afraid of No Regime
June 15, 2012
By Husam
ADC: Arab American Professionals’ Gateway to DC
June 12, 2012
By Hanitizer
Influence And Freedom
May 23, 2012
By Guest
Will Sacha Baron Cohen Bring His Muslim Bashing To An End?
May 22, 2012
By Hanitizer
On Chafed Oddballs, Siberian Socialites and Missed Opportunities
May 5, 2012
By Guest
A Single Roll of the Dice
April 23, 2012
By Guest